broadcast-channel-confidential-messages

Broadcast channel with common and confidential messages

Both receivers decode a common message; receiver 1 also decodes an independent confidential message kept secret from receiver 2.

Broadcast Wiretap Finite alphabet Discrete memoryless Secrecy Capacity region Exact Single-letter characterization

Channel and question

Input
A stochastic encoder maps independent uniform messages \(M_0,M_1\) to \(X^n\) over a finite alphabet, using private randomness.
Output
Receiver 1 observes \(Y^n\) and decodes both messages; receiver 2 observes \(Z^n\) and decodes \(M_0\).
Law
A fixed finite memoryless broadcast channel with marginals \(W_Y(y\mid x)\) and \(W_Z(z\mid x)\).
Quantity
Common-message and confidential-message capacity region \(\mathcal C_{\mathrm{BCC}}\), measured in bits per channel use.

Criterion. The closed set of nonnegative rate pairs \((R_0,R_1)\), normalized by blocklength, attainable at every sufficiently large blocklength with vanishing errors and normalized leakage.

  • There is no feedback, receiver cooperation, shared secret key, or input-cost constraint.
  • Each decoder uses only its own output. Arbitrary correlation between receiver outputs within a use does not change this operational region.
  • Both average decoding errors vanish, and weak secrecy requires \(I(M_1;Z^n)/n\to0\).

Current status

\[\mathcal C_{\mathrm{BCC}}=\overline{\bigcup_{U-V-X-(Y,Z)}\{(R_0,R_1)\ge0:\ R_0\le\min\{I(U;Y),I(U;Z)\},\ R_1\le I(V;Y\mid U)-I(V;Z\mid U)\}}\]

The union ranges over all finite auxiliaries and stochastic prefixes. This is the perfect-secrecy specialization of the Csiszár–Körner rate-equivocation region; Bloch–Laneman Theorem 3, equation (9), also states this region for weak-secrecy metric S4. No auxiliary-cardinality bound is imposed here.

Known results and bounds for Broadcast channel with common and confidential messages
ResultRelationMethodYear
Lower\(\mathcal C_{\mathrm{BCC}}\supseteq\overline{\bigcup_{U-V-X-(Y,Z)}\{(R_0,R_1)\ge0:\ R_0\le\min\{I(U;Y),I(U;Z)\},\ R_1\le I(V;Y\mid U)-I(V;Z\mid U)\}}\)Superposition coding, stochastic prefixing, and randomization for secrecy.1978
Upper\(\mathcal C_{\mathrm{BCC}}\subseteq\overline{\bigcup_{U-V-X-(Y,Z)}\{(R_0,R_1)\ge0:\ R_0\le\min\{I(U;Y),I(U;Z)\},\ R_1\le I(V;Y\mid U)-I(V;Z\mid U)\}}\)Fano inequalities, the Csiszár sum identity, and time sharing.1978

Formal verification

Lean coverageFormally stated

The local proof constructs stochastic block codes and proves achievability and converse, including zero-rate boundaries. It uses weak secrecy; it does not formalize strong secrecy or auxiliary-cardinality bounds.

Claims

  • The operational weak-secrecy region equals the closure of the finite-auxiliary common-message and confidential-message region.
    capacity-region · exact capacity · solved · Formally proved · v1
Lean declarations (4)

References

  1. Imre Csiszár and János Körner (1978). Broadcast Channels with Confidential Messages. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory. DOI 10.1109/TIT.1978.1055892.
  2. Matthieu R. Bloch and J. Nicholas Laneman (2013). Strong Secrecy from Channel Resolvability. IEEE Transactions on Information Theory.

Discussion

Related problems

The three-input Blackwell channel is a concrete nondegraded deterministic broadcast channel with an exact entropy capacity region.

Broadcast Finite alphabet Discrete memoryless Asymmetric Capacity region Exact Single-letter characterization
Solved \(R_1\le H(Y_1),\quad R_2\le H(Y_2),\quad R_1+R_2\le H(Y_1,Y_2)\)

A less-noisy ordering compares every finite stochastic prefix and yields the exact superposition-coding capacity region.

Broadcast Finite alphabet Discrete memoryless Capacity region Exact Single-letter characterization
Solved \(\mathcal C_{\mathrm{LN}}=\bigcup_{P_U P_{X|U}}\{R_1\le I(X;Y_1\mid U),\ R_2\le I(U;Y_2)\}\)

A more-capable ordering compares the receivers for every input distribution and yields an exact superposition-coding capacity region.

Broadcast Finite alphabet Discrete memoryless Capacity region Exact Single-letter characterization
Solved \(\mathcal C_{\mathrm{MC}}=\bigcup_{P_U P_{X|U}}\{R_2\le I(U;Y_2),\ R_1+R_2\le\min[I(X;Y_1),I(X;Y_1\mid U)+I(U;Y_2)]\}\)

Every sink recovers independent messages generated at several nodes. Linear network coding achieves exactly the cut constraints.

Multiple access Broadcast Finite alphabet Capacity region Exact Single-letter characterization
Solved \(\mathcal C=\{R\ge0:\ \sum_{i:s_i\in U}R_i\le\sum_{e\in\delta^+(U)}c_e\quad\forall t\in T,\ U\subseteq V\setminus\{t\}\}\)